New blood came on board in helping to organise the club and the addition of people like Charlie McEvoy (Offaly), Mick Keane (Galway) and the late Tony Spinner McLaughlin (Tyrone) brought with it an influx of new players and new energy. Their enthusiasm provided much needed oxygen to the club.
Meath man John Bennett was also a crucial part of the club in the mid-1990s, driving the side on from midfield and along with him, players such as the Galway duo of Donnacha Ryder and Mattie Kelly, who would both became fixtures on the team over the years, came along to galvanise the playing side even further.
The following years saw the club yo-yo between senior and intermediate, although they always struggled to make any huge impression at senior level and were generally scrapping for survival rather than silverware at the end of each season when they were at that level although a return to senior football did materialise in the late 1990s.
However, the development of young players had continued through the work of Monaghan man Brendan Sherry and his Hillingdon Gaels team. St Clarets inherited a host of new players into their ranks, most notably Brendan’s son Stevan, Dermot Wallace and John McDermott, all of whom were to be instrumental in the club winning the Intermediate Championship again in 1999, on a team that still contained many of the veterans of the 1989 team such as Martin Hession, John Kelly, Gerry Lynott and Colm Lynott. The club was developing a family-feel to it and as young men matured into family men, they brought their families along to the club with them. The club was fast becoming part of these people’s identities.
By that stage St Clarets had also added Offaly man Tony Murphy to their number and Murphy was to go on and bring great honour to the club in his time as a London senior player and also later as captain of the London junior team. Others from the club to represent London at senior level included Martin Hession, Brian McNiece, Stevan Sherry, Paddy Quinn, Mickey McConomy and the three Lynott brothers Colm, Gerry and the youngest Patrick.
And along the way the club was to have what has been, to date at least, its one and only dalliance with the real big time, the 2002 Senior Football Final, and as the football gods would deem it fit, they were pitted against their mother club and local rivals, St Brendans. Fittingly it was one of the local born players who captained the team that year, with Stevan Sherry leading the troops.
Alas the Clarets efforts were in vain, but that’s not to say that they didn’t leave a great impression of themselves that year. Nicknamed the Crazy Gang due to their refusal to pay any sort of respect to the more established members of the London football hierarchy, St Clarets brought a smile to the face of London football in 2002.
Still featuring many of the heroes of 1989, they had also added several very capable Irish players to their ranks in the likes of Declan McGeeney (Roscommon), Gerry Daly (Cork), Brian McNiece (Armagh), Eric Kinlon (Kildare), Alex McIndoo (Kerry) and the irrepressible Tyrone man Mickey McConomy. They reached that final in 2002 not because of luck, but because they deserved to and even beat the mighty Tir Chonaill Gaels en-route, Championship revenge at last for 1982.
But the club weren’t content just to rest on their laurels at that stage. In 2003 they lifted their first senior trophy winning the prestigious Tipperary Cup, thanks greatly to the efforts of another Tyrone man Paddy Quinn, who captained the side and several of his fellow Tyrone men like Paddy Donaghy and his brother Aiden.